Build Strength. Feel Capable. Live with Age 36 Energy.

How Do You Actually Know If Strength Training Is Working in Midlife?

One of the most common questions I get is this:

“How do I know if this is actually working?”

Not how long until I look different— but how do I know I’m not wasting my time with these workouts?

That’s a very reasonable question. Unfortunately, there isn’t one clear answer, which is why most of us are so unsure.

What’s more helpful—especially in midlife—is to look for convergence across a few areas. You don’t need all of them at once. You’re looking for patterns over time.

Why This Question Matters More in Midlife

In your 20s or 30s, you could often rely on fast, visible feedback. Do the workouts. Feel sore. See changes.

Midlife bodies are different. Progress tends to be more nuanced. And much less Instagram-friendly.

That doesn’t mean your training isn’t working. It means you need to know which signals actually matter.

Signal 1: Performance Is Trending Up

The first place I look is performance.

I’m not seeking dramatic progress, or even linear progress—because we all know it doesn’t happen in a straight line.

I’m looking for small signs that things are shifting.

Exercises that once felt shaky now feel more controlled
Lifting still feels challenging, but also less effortful
You recover a little faster between sets

These changes are subtle, which is why people miss them. But it’s important to look for them, because if nothing about performance changes over months, that’s information, too. It may mean your workouts aren’t actually working for you.

Signal 2: Daily Life Feels More Tolerant

This one matters a lot to me.

After all—why are we trying to get stronger if not to continue enjoying our lives?

You might notice things like:

Carrying groceries without bracing your entire body
Being more inclined to take the stairs
Getting up or down from the floor without really thinking about it

You’re not looking for superhero strength.You’re feeling more capable with less friction. That usually points to effective training.

Signal 3: Your Body Handles Stress Better

Strength training isn’t effective if it constantly costs more than it gives— especially in midlife.

It’s often easier to notice when things aren’t working:

You’re always sore
You dread sessions
You feel flattened afterward
Sleep suffers
Recovery never quite catches up

Those are signs your training is depleting you. And when recovery stalls, adaptation usually does too. That’s the opposite of what we want.

Signal 4: You Stop Chasing Novelty

This one surprises people.

When training is working, you feel less urge to constantly switch programs. You’re not chasing the next fix because you trust the process enough to stay with it.

That psychological steadiness matters–and it’s an underrated signal that you’re on the right track.

Signal 5: Aesthetics Lag—and That’s Okay

This is the part most people hate.

Seeing visible proof of your efforts—often called “muscle tone”—usually lags behind strength gains. Fluctuating hormones can make it take longer for visible muscle to show up. Fat distribution plays a role too.

So appearance alone can’t be the judge. Here’s what is worth remembering:

If performance and capacity are improving, aesthetics usually follow.

(Just not on the timeline social media promises.)

So… How Do You Know If It’s Working?

Effectiveness isn’t something you prove instantly. It’s something you infer over time–through patience, pattern recognition, and tolerating some ambiguity.

But most people want certainty, so they default to:

The scale
Soreness
Exhaustion
Trackers

Learning to tolerate that nuance is often more realistic—and more useful.

One Simple Experiment to Try

Commit to one strength-training approach for the next 30 days.

Don’t change it. Don’t optimize it. Just stay with it.

Then pay attention. You should notice at least a few of the signals above, though more meaningful feedback often shows up closer to 8–12 weeks. The real goal here is trust—in the process, and in your commitment.

Strength rewards consistency over time.

Where to Go Next

If you’re looking for a strength-training approach you can actually stay with, that’s exactly what we do inside The Wonderfulness Community.

But if you’re not ready for that yet, start with the Age-Proofing Strength Blueprint— a clear, grounded way to understand how to train your midlife body with confidence.

Get more like this by subscribing HERE to The Wonderfulness Newsletter