Don’t Mistake What You Have Been Doing for What You Can Do


Get Stronger After 40

Don’t Mistake What You Have Been Doing for What You Can Do

"I've never been athletic."

"I'm not disciplined."

"I'm not one of those women who likes exercise."

I've heard versions of these for years. Let me be honest—I’ve said versions of them, as well. Usually they're offered as explanations, but they act more like conclusions. The statements become labels, perhaps even our personal brand. Apparently some women are naturally active, naturally strong, naturally disciplined, and the rest of us just got assigned different personalities at birth.

It's strange when you think about it because we don't usually talk this way about other skills. Nobody says, "I'm just not one of those women who brushes her teeth" or "I'm simply not wired to eat carrots.” We understand that most things become familiar because we repeatedly do them. But we treat exercise and physical capability like personality traits.

Capability is surprisingly indifferent to who we think we are. It’s built through exposure and repetition. Most women weren't born loving strength training. They weren't born knowing how to squat, deadlift, balance on one leg, or consistently show up for workouts. They became more comfortable with those things because they did them repeatedly. Exposure slowly became familiarity, and familiarity started feeling natural.

I think many of us mistake history for identity. If you've spent years avoiding exercise, feeling awkward in gym spaces, or repeatedly stopping and starting, eventually that experience can start to feel like evidence. See? I've never been one of those women. But what if you've simply had more repetition being someone who doesn't exercise?

Humans adapt remarkably well and we become comfortable with what we repeatedly experience. We can become comfortable avoiding challenge. We can even become dependent on comfort itself. And then we believe this story we’re creating: I'm just not disciplined. I'm just not athletic. I'm just not that kind of person.

But those labels often describe your past experience—not your future potential. You don't become someone who lifts weights because you discovered your hidden fitness personality. You become her because you repeatedly lifted weights.

We spend a lot of time waiting to feel like the kind of woman who is strong and confident in her body. But identity tends to be built after the behavior, not before it. In other words, you will become the woman you've repeatedly practiced being.


You can try it out for yourself by downloading a free 8-minute workout video. Start practicing now. See how you feel about yourself after a week.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Copyright © 2026 Marci Bowman | The Wonderfulness Community. All rights reserved.

The Wonderfulness Newsletter | Strength for Women 40+

The shared posts below are public. The newsletter keeps you closer. Subscribe to get my weekly article delivered straight to your inbox, plus useful links, fresh ideas, and first access to workouts, offers, and community opportunities for women who want to get stronger with age.

Read more from The Wonderfulness Newsletter | Strength for Women 40+
woman in vintage bolero jacket holding weight by chin

Get Stronger After 40 Join The Wonderfulness Community “Listening to Your Body” Doesn’t Mean Letting It Off the Hook “Listen to your body” started as good advice. For a long time, many of us were encouraged to override every signal our bodies sent. Our culture urged us to push harder, wear exhaustion like a badge of honor, and walk it off when it hurt. We were told that soreness was weakness leaving the body. If you weren't suffering, apparently you weren't really trying. So “listen to your...

Get Stronger After 40 Join The Wonderfulness Community Your Workouts Are Teaching You Something More Important Than Strength Show of hands: Who wants to become rigid, closed off, resistant, fragile, predictable, or smaller versions of themselves? Okay. Now who wants to be comfortable all the time? Sorry. If you don’t want the first one, then you can’t have the second one—because humans adapt brilliantly. Unfortunately, we don't just adapt to challenge—we adapt to comfort too. In other words,...

blonde woman leaning into laptop screen

Get Stronger After 40 Join The Wonderfulness Community Congratulations. You've Been Successfully Outsourced. By the time a woman is past forty, she’s tried at least 283 different things that are supposed to help improve her health. Okay, I completely made that number up, but it sounds feasible. Between programs, supplements, challenges, meal plans, morning routines, special equipment, color-coded accountability charts, and trackers that politely inform you that you’re even failing at...